GOOS Book Distilled Part 7

A follow through of the great book Growing Object-Oriented Software, Guided by Tests with code

2 minute read

Let’s start off by taking a closer look at our AuctionSniper. Notice that it implements AuctionEventListener, which means it is now mainly a listener. It listens to AuctionMessageTranslator, and for now, it only implements auctionClosed(). So the next step would naturally be to implement currentPrice(). It is not hard to find out that when receives a PRICE update, the sniper should do 2 things:

  1. Sends a higher bid.
  2. Display status as BIDDING in UI.

The second one is easy, we just use SniperListener. But where do we put the function to send a bidding message?

We introduce another new class, Auction. And put the message sending logic into it.

Now, AuctionSniper has two responsibilities:

  1. Notify status change through SniperListener.
  2. Make bid through Auction.

There was a split of a second that we considered adding the sending bid messages into SniperListener, but quickly dismissed the thought because the SniperListener is a notification not a dependency. Subtle design decisions like this is crucial to keep the architecture of the software reasonable.

Since this is an important concept, I quote the definitions from the book:

Dependencies Services that the object requires from its peers so it can perform its responsibilities. The object cannot function without these services. It should not be possible to create the object without them. For example, a graphics package will need something like a screen or canvas to draw on—it doesn’t make sense without one.

Notifications Peers that need to be kept up to date with the object’s activity. The object will notify interested peers whenever it changes state or performs a significant action. Notifications are “fire and forget”; the object neither knows nor cares which peers are listening. Notifications are so useful because they decouple objects from each other. For example, in a user interface system, a button component promises to notify any registered listeners when it’s clicked, but does not know what those listeners will do. Similarly, the listeners expect to be called but know nothing of the way the user interface dispatches its events.

Source code

comments powered by Disqus